1. Key Challenges

Limited Local Talent Pool

  • Small domestic population combined with an ageing workforce: Many jurisdictions face demographic challenges — low birth rates and an ageing workforce mean fewer working-age locals entering professional roles. This contributes to labour shortages and skills gaps in areas like finance, tech, and specialised services
  • Skills mismatch: Many local jobseekers lack the qualifications or experience required for modern professional roles — especially in the finance, tech, and compliance sectors

Immigration and Work Permits

  • Work permit requirements: Many territories prioritise local citizens for jobs. Employers must demonstrate that no qualified local exists before hiring expatriates — a process that can be administratively heavy and uncertain, especially with policy tightening
  • Policy enforcement: Increasingly stringent approaches on permit conditions, such as mandatory local training plans, can create uncertainty or delays and sometimes discourage firms from hiring

High Cost of Living and Compensation Pressures

  • The cost-of-living barrier: Salaries must necessarily be high enough to compensate for expensive housing, education, and living costs, particularly in high-profile business centres such as the Cayman Islands and Bermuda. This reduces the financial attractiveness for expatriate hires and raises overall labour costs

Retention and Competition

  • Retention of skilled employees: Limited career progression paths, competition among local firms, and the lure of larger financial centres can make retaining trained professionals a challenge
  • Advancement concerns: There can be the perception amongst Belongers or PRC holders that guest workers dominate senior roles, dampening training uptake and progression for local staff

Recruitment Infrastructure Gaps

  • Limited job-matching tools: Sites, portals and recruitment channels sometimes fail to effectively match local talent with opportunities, adding friction to the hiring process
  • Industry-education disconnect: Employers report gaps between what education systems produce and what businesses need in practical terms of technical and soft skills

2. Effective Solutions

Invest in Training and Local Upskilling

  • Workforce development programmes: Companies can partner with local institutions to offer internships, apprenticeships, and tailored training to build needed skills — particularly in finance, tech, and compliance. This expands the local candidate pool over time
  • Soft skills and career pathways: Embedding mentoring, coaching, and leadership training into organisations improves local workforce readiness and retention

Strategic Use of Immigration Pathways

  • Clear work permit strategy: Establish a structured process for local recruitment before submitting permit applications, including strong documentation of efforts to hire Bermudians or Caymanians
  • Policy awareness: Stay updated on regulations (like Bermuda’s 2025 work permit policy changes) so that your company’s hiring plans align with compliance requirements

Leverage External HR and Recruitment Support

  • Executive search agencies: Working with specialist recruiters (for example, Hamilton Recruitment) who understand the local market and professional networks can improve access to passive candidates and fill hard-to-reach roles
  • Employer of Record (EOR) service providers: For companies without legal local entities and depending on jurisdiction, an EOR might be useful in hiring staff, handle payroll, benefits, and permit sponsorship, reducing administrative burden and compliance risk

Enhance Compensation and Benefits

  • Competitive packages: Offer compensation that accounts for cost of living (e.g. housing allowances, education support) and benefits (health insurance, retirement plans) to attract both local and expatriate talent
  • Flexible work options: Hybrid or remote work arrangements can broaden candidate pools and make roles more appealing

Government & Community Initiatives

  • Public-private partnerships: Collaborate on government workforce initiatives to influence training curricula, certification programmes, and labour policy that better meet industry needs
  • Supporting local employment: Align with national goals to upskill and employ Bermudians/Caymanians, demonstrating commitment to local prosperity while leveraging expertise gaps

Improve Staff Retention

  • Clear career ladders: Help employees visualise long-term growth paths to reduce turnover
  • Promote an inclusive culture: Foster supportive environments that value diversity, mentorship, and cross-cultural competencies, which will aid retention and performance

If you want a job on the Islands, visit our jobs portal to see the latest vacancies.

Are you hiring? Book a Discovery Call if you’re hiring and see how we can help.

Actuarial | Audit & Advisory | Corporate Services | Finance | Insolvency & Restructuring | Legal | Regulatory & Compliance | Trusts | US Tax